AI is everywhere in marketing and customer experience. It’s writing emails, answering questions, generating social content and guiding product recommendations. But as automation scales, something else is becoming more valuable — something AI can’t replicate.
Human connection.
In 2026, the brands that win attention and trust won’t be the ones that automate the most. They’ll be the ones who use AI wisely but double down on authenticity, emotional intelligence and real human presence.
Despite the hype, most customers don’t want a fully automated experience. In fact, 93.4% of U.S. consumers say they prefer interacting with a human over AI for customer service, according to OutreachX’s report, “If Bots Handle Support, Who Handles Trust?” It also found 88.8% believe companies should always offer that option. That’s not a glitch in the adoption curve — it’s a signal.
“In 2026, the brands that forgo human connection will lose,” said Mike Donoghue, CEO and co-founder of Subtext. “AI is turning communication into a commodity… It boils down to the fact that people want to talk through machines, not to machines.”
Speed and scale matter, but not at the expense of feeling heard.
The backlash against AI is real
Customers are losing patience with AI that doesn’t understand them — and they’re walking away. Nearly half (49.6%) say they would cancel a service if AI-only support were their only option, according to the OutreachX report. That’s a significant risk for brands that bet everything on automation.
Even more telling: while 90% of companies think customers are satisfied with conversational AI, according to Twilio’s “Inside the Conversational AI Revolution” report, only 59% of customers agree. That’s a 31-point satisfaction gap.
Dig deeper: What happens when no one clicks anymore
Consumers report that AI too often feels robotic (51%), fails to understand what they’re asking (66%) and doesn’t resolve their issue (49%). When they’re stressed or dealing with complex problems, they want empathy — and they don’t trust a bot to deliver it.
Authenticity is no longer optional
The flood of AI-generated content is making people more skeptical about what they see online — and more drawn to what feels real. In Sprout Social’s “2025 Q3 Pulse Survey,” the top concern consumers had about brand behavior on social media was posting AI-generated content without disclosing it.
And consumers aren’t that much happier when it is disclosed. Coke released an AI-created holiday ad for the second year in a row, and backlash to it may become a new Christmas tradition. In the Netherlands, McDonald’s had to pull its “It’s the Most Terrible Time of the Year” ad. Consumers said it was “soulless,” “depressing” and “anti-festive,” and the AI visuals were called “glitchy,” “creepy” and falling into the “uncanny valley.”
The Sprout Social research also found that 55% of people — and 66% of Gen Z and Millennials — are more likely to trust brands that publish human-generated content. By Q4, the message was even clearer: the #1 effort consumers want brands to prioritize in 2026 is crafting human-generated content.
As Zoom CMO Kim Storin said, “The ethical line in marketing won’t be drawn by what AI can do, but by what we choose to let it do.”
The future is human-AI collaboration
None of this means AI doesn’t have a place — it absolutely does. But the brands seeing long-term success are building hybrid models, where AI handles execution and humans steer the message.
“This growing movement toward automation raises questions about the future role of human marketers,” said Max Thomas, founder of business consultancy TBP Global Assets. “The critical factor will be the ability to blend innovations with strategic human insight.”
That blend is becoming its own competitive advantage. As the volume of automated content rises, human oversight becomes the quality filter.
Consumers don’t just want transparency — they expect it
There’s a clear disconnect between what businesses think AI is delivering and how customers perceive it. More than 80% of consumers believe AI is used mainly to save companies money — not to improve their experience.
Dig deeper: How the new attention standards turn feeling into data
And trust isn’t just about performance — it’s about transparency. Customers want to know what’s automated, how their data is used and where the human touch still exists.
Sprout Social CMO Scott Morris put it plainly: “Authenticity will shift from brand differentiator to prerequisite.”
The bottom line
AI can absolutely help brands scale. It can improve speed, consistency and personalization. But it cannot replace what customers value most when the stakes are high: empathy, trust and human understanding. The brands that succeed in 2026 won’t be the ones that automate every interaction. They’ll be the ones that know what to automate — and what should stay human.
Fuel up with free marketing insights.
MarTech is owned by Semrush. We remain committed to providing high-quality coverage of marketing topics. Unless otherwise noted, this page’s content was written by either an employee or a paid contractor of Semrush Inc.
